Cooking butternut squash becomes easier with the help of an air fryer! Tossed in garlic and herbs, air fryer butternut squash is perfectly flavored and especially tender, without having to use a lot of oil. This recipe is the perfect Thanksgiving side dish, or the leftover squash could also be used in tacos, quiches, and salads.
When it comes to new kitchen technology, I’m a bit slow to adapt. It took me a long time to try the Instant Pot, which I absolutely love. And it took me just as long to try an air fryer, which is pretty great too! I mean, Air Fryer Chocolate Chip Cookies are a thing. Who knew?!
I spent a lot of time testing this butternut squash recipe for you, wanting to highlight the all-star fall vegetable.
Why Make Butternut Squash in the Air Fryer
Rather than roasting, using your air fryer to make butternut squash takes a mere 20 minutes, and the resulting texture and flavor is amazing. It’s especially good as a side dish served with this Spinach Stuffed Salmon.
To flavor the butternut squash, I used a simple garlic herb combination. Coating in a mix of Watkins Organic Spices and Spice Blends, including Organic Italian Seasoning, Organic Garlic Powder, and Pink Himalayan Salt, the squash is seasoned all the way through with robust taste. It would also be a great seasoning mix for Air Fryer Garlic Fries!
Tip for making vegetables in the Air Fryer:
I’ve found that using dried herbs to season ingredients that will be cooked in an air fryer is superior to using fresh, as those burn quickly from the high, concentrated heat.
This air fryer butternut squash is a great Thanksgiving side dish, but its versatility means you can add it to other recipes that call for roasted butternut squash, like this delicious Wild Rice Harvest Salad.
How to Cut Butternut Squash
Use a sharp vegetable peeler to remove the skin from the squash. You don’t want their to be any beige/white streaks left on the squash.
Trim both ends off of the squash.
At the point where the long neck of the squash meets the round bottom, cut it horizontally, so you know have two pieces to work with. Cut the bottom in half vertically, and scoop out seeds.
Beginning with the long neck, cut 1/2 inch slices. Stack two or three slices, and cut into cubes.
How to Make Air Fryer Butternut Squash
Peel and cube butternut squash.
Add to a bowl and toss with olive oil, garlic powder, and herbs.
Preheat air fryer to 375 degrees F. Place on air fryer trays, as close to single layers as you can achieve.
Put trays on middle and lower racks. Cook for 8 minutes, then shake and swap trays, the higher tray going lower, the lower tray going higher. Cook for another 10 minutes.
Turn air fryer off, and let squash sit in oven for 5 minutes. This is important, as it lets the squash finish cooking without burning. Enjoy!
As you likely know, there are many different kinds of air fryers. They generally fall into two categories: basket air fryers and convection oven air fryers. I have the Instant Vortex Plus Air Fryer Oven 7 in 1 with Rotisserie, which is a convection oven air fryer, with racks to place food on and added air frying functionality.
I tested this recipe using the rotisserie basket that the Instant Pot Air Fryer comes with too, and the results were excellent! I give both instructions in the recipe card below.
1pound4 ounces(550 grams) of peeled, cubed butternut squash (1/2 inch cubes)
1 1/2tablespoonsextra virgin olive oil
3/4teaspoonWatkins Himalayan Pink Salt
1teaspoonWatkins Organic Garlic Powder
2teaspoonsWatkins Organic Italian Seasoning
Prevent your screen from going dark
Add cubed squash to a bowl and toss with olive oil, salt, garlic powder, and Italian Seasoning.
Preheat air fryer to 375 degrees F. Place squash on air fryer trays, as close to single layers as you can achieve. *see notes below for air fryer rotisserie basket instructions*
Put trays on middle and lower racks. Cook for 8 minutes, then shake and swap trays, the higher tray going lower, the lower tray going higher. Cook for another 8 minutes. Check to see if squash is tender and a fork can easily pierce through. If so, continue to step 4. If not, cook for 2-3 more minutes, then continue. (Each air fryer is different, so it will affect cooking time. In the end, you’re going for crispy edged, tender inside cubes of squash.)
Turn air fryer off, and let squash sit in oven for 5 minutes This helps it to continue to cook through, at a lower temp, avoiding burning it. Remove from and serve warm.
*If you have an air fryer rotisserie basket, you can add seasoned squash to the basket, and cook for 24 minutes at 400 degrees F on the air fryer setting.*If you have a standard air fryer cooking basket, add seasoned squash to the basket and cook for 20 minutes at 400 degrees F, shaking the basket twice during cooking.