I love making a big batch of these tender, creamy white beans simmered with garlic and bay leaves for the week ahead. Then I fry fresh sage leaves into crunchy, delicate bliss, along with capers for a salty, earthy pop. YUM. A big drizzle olive adds to the salty broth and gives them the most luxurious flavor. Use dried cannellini or Great Northern beans, both get silky and creamy.
These Tuscan white beans seem way too simple to be amazing, but truly, they are.
Tender, creamy beans simmered with garlic, bay leaves, and sage, then finished with a generous pour of really good olive oil, crispy fried sage, and salty little capers. Simple ingredients, big payoff.
I make a big pot on the weekend and eat them all week. This is one of those recipes I like to make and then work into different meals all week long. I’ll eat them alongside a juicy grilled flank steak or toss them into this warm roasted broccoli and cauliflower salad – they’re phenomenal together!
I love that I can skip the overnight soak and still get the absolute perfect, creamy texture with the instant pot. If you don’t have an Instant Pot, no worries, the stovetop works too. You’ll just want to soak your beans in the fridge overnight first. (And if you’re already pulling out the Instant Pot, my instant pot white bean soup is another favorite.)
Grab cannellini or Great Northern beans, both get silky and creamy.
Cannellini beans show up a lot in Italian cooking, and Great Northern beans work just as well. Cooked right, both turn silky smooth with a slightly nutty flavor.
Fried sage and capers are my little upgrade.
In Tuscany, beans are such a staple that Tuscans are nicknamed mangiafagioli, or bean eaters. They’re usually made very simply, with herbs and lots of fresh olive oil, and that’s exactly where this recipe starts.
Then I take it one step further. I fry fresh sage leaves into crunchy, delicate bliss, along with capers for a salty, earthy pop. YUM.
Use the best olive oil your wallet can afford, you’ll really taste it.
The extra virgin olive oil isn’t just a drizzle here, it’s a big part of the dish. You’ll taste its rich, luxurious, fruity flavor in every bite, so make sure it’s one you actually love the taste of.
You can make these a day ahead, just save the sage for last.
A reader asked me this, and the answer is definitely! Cook the beans the day before, then fry the sage leaves right before serving so they stay crispy.
Brothy Tuscan White Beans (instant pot or stovetop)
Tender, creamy cannellini beans simmered with garlic, bay leaves, and sage, then finished with good olive oil, crispy fried sage, and salty capers. Make them in the Instant Pot with no soaking, or on the stovetop, both work great!
This recipe can be made with your instant pot (pressure cooker) or on the stovetop. For instant pot, add beans (unsoaked), water, salt, garlic, bay leaves, and 3 sprigs fresh sage to the cooking pot.
Set to manual high pressure for 30 minutes. Let come to pressure and cook. When finished, let pot natural release for 20 minutes, then finish releasing steam manually.
If you are cooking the beans on the stovetop, plan on soaking beans overnight in refrigerator. When ready to make, add beans, water, salt, garlic, bay leaves, and 3 sprigs fresh sage to the cooking pot. On a low simmer, cook until beans are plump and tender, but not mushy.
Meanwhile, add 1 tablespoon olive oil to a small skillet and turn to medium heat. Once hot, add sage leaves, individually, and capers. Let cook for a few minutes on each side, turning over as they cook until crispy. Place sage and capers on a napkin.
Drain beans, reserving 1 cup broth. Add beans and broth to a serving bowl, and pour olive oil over the top, and adorn with fried sage leaves and capers. Finish with flaky salt and cracked black pepper.
I look forward to your comments, reviews and questions! If you love this recipe, please rate it when you leave a comment. Star ratings help people discover my recipes. Your support means a lot; thank you for being a part of the Heartbeet Kitchen community.
Athina Levesque
August 8, 2024
Hi! This recipe looks great. My question-can these be made the day before? Thanks!
Amanda Paa
August 8, 2024
Definitely! Just do the fried sage leaves right before serving.