This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
You know the reaction. The one you get when you’re out for breakfast and you order oatmeal….. the nose scrunched, shocked stare from across the table. And then the slew of questions — “are you sure you don’t want the eggs benedict? or how about french toast? are you trying to eat healthy? that’s so boring.” This probably coming from the person who was served super sweet maple brown sugar instant oatmeal packets as a kid, with the gummiest texture, that got even worse as they sat with one hand on their head, the other holding the spoon, defying to eat it.
But really, oats are one of my favorite things to eat. Naturally a little sweet and nutty, versatile, full of whole grain power, cheap, cozy, and satisfying.
Muesli is made of oats and accompaniments, sort of like an un-baked, raw granola. It originated in Switzerland and is quite popular around Europe, but I’m seeing it much more often in the US these days. Comprised of dry, rolled oats and sometimes other grains, nuts and seeds, maybe flaked coconut, warm spices, and dried fruit, muesli is like the chex mix of oatmeal. And I love it.
Cold, soaked muesli is great in the summertime, and keeps the ingredients in their purest form. But I also like to make it warm via a breakfast bake, and change the fruit that sinks into its top as the seasons change. And during the summer, it changes nearly weekly, as the peak season for each fruit comes and go quickly. In July, it was cherries and blueberries, in August, this Peach Baked Muesli, taking advantage of the stone fruit gold mine.
It’s quite easy and memorable, one you probably won’t even need the recipe for once you make it a few times. Muesli, milk, butter, a little bit of maple syrup, and one egg. The liquids are whisked to wet the dry mixture, and layered with fruit and pecans in a large pan.
At first you’ll think there is way too much liquid, but it has a purpose, softening the oats and accompaniments in the muesli, and keep it moist throughout the baking process.
I can’t get over the intoxicating smell as this baked museli is in the oven…. the cinnamon and nutmeg mingling with the fruit, and the pecans toasting away. It comes out tender and sliceable, full of flavor despite the simplicity. And perhaps the biggest benefit is that it makes a large batch, perfect for baking on Sunday and eating throughout the week, warm or cold.
Sometimes I top the squares with a dollop of yogurt, but always, always a drizzle of pure maple syrup and a splash of cream.
tag @heartbeetkitchen on instagram and hashtag it #heartbeetkitchen
Marlene Carlson
July 24, 2024
Can I make this recipe without half & half
Alexandra
July 22, 2022
I was looking for this weekend’s breakfast and this popped into my inbox at the perfect moment! Would you imagine almond or coconut milk/cream/yogurt would be just as delicious for this? Also, I have been curious as to what raw milk has to offer- lots of health hype buzzing around it. Any general opinion? (Although this is baked so I realize it wouldn’t matter here necessarily).
Amanda Paa
July 22, 2022
Hello! Yes, almond or coconut milk works great here. Just make sure that the brand you use is around the same fat content as dairy milk. I don’t have any experience with raw milk, sorry!
Cynthia Swienton
July 22, 2022
I’m going to try and veganize this! My husband bought two bags of muesli after I bought four big bags! I’ll let you know how it comes out!
Amanda Paa
July 22, 2022
Yes, let me know!
Kristina @ Vibrant Plate
October 6, 2016
This is such a great idea! I like cold oatmeal, but not in winter time, but don’t like cooked porridge so much, so this looks like a great in-between. Definitely giving this a try and pinned it for later. Thanks!
amandapaa
October 7, 2016
It’s a great in between! Just make sure that if your muesli doesn’t have lovely spices like nutmeg and cinnamon, to add them as needed. It really enhances the flavor of the peaches. xo
Carrie
September 13, 2016
I just stumbled on your blog and was reading your bio – I, too, am from New Ulm :) I moved to the cities when I was 13 months old (Prior Lake…now Lakeville), but my sister and her family still live there. I look forward to following your posts now! THIS one in particular…yum! Sounds and looks incredible!
amandapaa
September 13, 2016
What a fun connection! I’m actually heading back home this weekend. :) Thanks so much for stopping by, and if you try the muesli, let me know how you like it! xo
Emily
September 7, 2016
Just getting caught up on blog-reading and having so much fun looking through all of your posts! I’m totally with you- I’ve ordered oatmeal at restaurants too and friends think I’m crazy, but I love it. Such a great idea to incorporate muesli into a baked oatmeal and those peaches make it beautiful in such a summer-y way. (So sad for the end of peach season…. wah!)
Cassie
September 3, 2016
Baking muesli?! That is SUCH a genius idea! I’d LOVE LOVE LOVE to try out this recipe! Oh yes, and brunch temptations are SO real. “Look at these maple spelt PANCAKES! Have some TRUFFLE FRIES! I absolutely love my AVOCADO TOAST!” :)
amandapaa
September 3, 2016
oh, i hope you do it try it! i’ve made it several times, and i even freeze a few of the extra slices for rushed mornings. also, i can’t quit avocado toast either. :)
Jennifer Farley
September 2, 2016
What a beautiful presentation of muesli!
amandapaa
September 3, 2016
thank you so much jennifer! sunken fruit is such a pretty thing.
Jessica @ A Kitchen Addiction
September 1, 2016
Oatmeal is my go-to breakfast, because I love how versatile it can be! I need to try this baked muesli soon!
Bethany @ Athletic Avocado
September 1, 2016
Ughhhh I also LOVE oatmeal and order in restaurants, no shame here! I’ve actually never really tried muesli, but this would be a great recipe to start! Drooling!
Alanna
August 30, 2016
Gah, this is drop dead gorgeous Amanda! I will be making this asap. <3
Agnes {Cashew Kitchen}
August 30, 2016
Mmmm yummy! I love oatmeal and bircher muesli and everything granola related, so I’m sure I would love this recipe as well! We eat a ton of muesli here in Sweden, but I’ve never actually seen a baked version of Bircher Muesli (overnight muesli). Only baked oatmeal, but sometimes it can be a little boring with only oats. Will try this recipe soon <3 I can imagine it spreads the most wonderful smells in the kitchen!
Lovely photography as well!
xx Agnes
Ruby
August 30, 2016
I have never thought of baked muesli before, but this looks amazingly delicious! So glad muesli is making its way to the US little by little :) Can’t wait to try this!! xo
Alison @Food by Mars
August 29, 2016
Oh sweet peaches that looks good. I love cinnamon and nutmeg with them too – they belong together, don’t they? I’ve tried baked oatmeal but this is next level, will need to give this a try… xo
amandapaa
August 30, 2016
Cinnamon, nutmeg, peaches. Be still my heart. I love this bake so much, and can’t wait to make it with apples too. xo!