This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure policy.
I had two goals in mind when creating this recipe.
First, to help you love eggplant. That they aren’t bitter and flavorless, when prepared with a little insight. The tricks I share below got me over my fear of eggplants and taught me how to crave these delightful purple globes.
And second, to show you that muenster cheese is for far more than a deli sandwich.
Actually, now that I think about it, a third thing: that vegetarian meals don’t have to be boring or difficult to make! You only need 5 ingredients to make these Cheesy Marinara Baked Eggplant Slices, which is a dish full of flavor and texture. I’d compare the taste to that of an incredible cheese pizza!
Let’s dive into taking the bitterness out of eggplant.
Simply salt the eggplant (generously) while you’re waiting for the oven to heat up, then pat the eggplant dry after 30 minutes with a paper towel. The salt draws the bitter liquid out of the eggplant while seasoning the eggplant from the inside out at the same time. It’s especially important if you’re buying eggplant from a grocery store because they’re older, rather than a farmer’s market, where the vegetables were recently picked.
Roasting the eggplant slices before assembling the rest of the dishes is key too. It brings out the sweetness of eggplant, and any extra moisture, before the slices are nestled into your favorite marinara sauce. I prefer Rao’s, which is incredibly flavorful and just as good, if not better than homemade.
Eggplant, tomatoes, and basil go together so well, a staple pairing in Italian cooking. But whereas you might find mozzarella or parmesan as the cheese component, I’ve discovered the cheese that that’ll give you both flavor and melts wonderfully, that perfect elasticity that makes for epic cheese pulls…. Tillamook Muenster Slices, I’m looking at you!
Under the heat of the oven, it turns this dish into something special. The Muenster has a mildly nutty flavor, and browns and bubbles like a champ.
Assembling this layered dish is easy. You’ll cover the bottom with marinara sauce, add a layer of the roasted eggplant slices, spread a dollop of marinara on their centers, then a layer of the Muenster slices, fresh basil leaves. Then top each stack with another slice of eggplant, more marinara and a final layer of Muenster.
Two layers of cheesy goodness. A gluten-free dinner recipe that will be a hit.
And exactly what your summer abundance of eggplant is begging to be turned into!
tag @heartbeetkitchen on instagram and hashtag it #heartbeetkitchen
Stef
August 23, 2024
I would have never thought to use Muenster but it’s great! I made enough for two meals. Tomorrow, I’ll add some parmesan on top. I made my own sauce so this took longer than this recipe’s time estimates. So good!
Amanda Paa
August 23, 2024
Oh, your own sauce; awesome!! Love adding a little parm to top too. Thanks for making the recipe!
Jay
June 13, 2024
An excellent dish! I added mushroom pieces between the marinara and the last Muenster level. It was a lot more filling than I thought it would be.
Amanda Paa
June 13, 2024
Oh yum, sounds awesome with the added mushrooms! Thanks for making the recipe.
Rebecca I Kirk
September 26, 2023
Haven’t baked it yet. Looking forward to doing so this week.
It would be helpful to have a recommendation for the size of the baking pan.
Amanda Paa
September 27, 2023
Great suggestion; I use an 11×7 inch pan!
Mags
September 10, 2023
Ha Ha there were no leftovers!
Nicole
April 30, 2022
Delicious… the Muenster is the secret ingredient!
Amanda Paa
April 30, 2022
totally agree!
Renu Mann
October 3, 2021
This recipe was perfect as I grew tomatoes, basil and eggplant in my kitchen garden this year. I used Havarti cheese and it came out fantastic. Most recipes suggest frying as first step which I wanted to avoid, so this was just perfect.
Amanda Paa
October 3, 2021
Yes, Havarti is a fabulous melting cheese too, so great choice! Glad you liked the recipe.
Faye
April 10, 2021
Hi! I made this in a single laye -just on olive oiled cookie sheet, w sauce I made (with garlic onions and fresh tomatoes spices etc) for spaghetti & meatballs at the same time :) didn’t have basil but used Italian seasoning and some I did w Munster, some fresh mozzarella, some both. It was great!
Veronika
December 5, 2020
Can i use different type of cheese? Any recommendation?
Amanda Paa
December 5, 2020
Yes, mozzarella would also work great!
Tati_yabish
February 1, 2020
Made this recipe! Super fun super quick super easy. Unfortunately I didn’t have the basil leaves :( The eggplant smelled so good after being baked the first 15 minutes. I highly recommend this recipe to mg cheese lovers!!!
Amanda Paa
February 2, 2020
So glad you enjoyed the recipe!