Local Gems: 8 Great Places to Eat in Fort Myers, Florida

By Amanda Paa – Updated January 27, 2023

It’s been a long winter in Minnesota. And although I love the season as much as any northerner, a vacation from the snow and cold is one of the ways we make it through. This year we made our trip about both family and vacation, and went to visit Brian’s mom and husband who keep a winter home in Fort Myers, Florida.

Referred to as snowbirds, they are those who leave their cold-weather hometowns for a month or more in the winter, and keep a temporary residence in warm-weather locales. Retirees from the East Coast have traditionally gravitated to the eastern part of Florida, while many from the Midwest go to Florida’s west coast such as the Fort Myers and Sanibel area. Those from Western states venture south to destinations such as Phoenix and Santa Fe.

Barefoot Beach, Fort Myers, Florida
Sanibel Beach // Vacation in Fort Myers

So why I am telling you those details? Well, I learned it’s better to go into your visit knowing that it’s an older population that lives here, so the restaurant scene may not be as elevated, or as modern, as what you’re used to if you live in a metropolitan area.

That being said, we did find some several local places to eat in Fort Myers, hidden gems, that I’m sharing with you today, and the main reason to go — beaches!

And the sun soaked 80 degree days. The softest white sand, blue and turquoise water, and some of the best shelling in the world. Don’t miss Barefoot Beach Preserve, just south of Fort Myers Beach. You can walk along the entire shoreline, and it is much less crowded than other beaches. It’s where the locals go!

Best places to eat in downtown Fort Myers and surrounding area:

  • Bennett’s Fresh Roast: Completely a hidden treasure. Imagine the “Cheers” of a bakery, hand-cut from scratch doughnuts and fresh roasted coffee, everyday. All the old time varieties you could think of, and some a bit fancier like Maple Bacon. The coffee was the best we had the entire visit, definitely to my surprise!
  • Green Cup Organic Cafe: I had such high hopes for this quaint spot. The design was beautiful and the menu had all the last and greatest food trends. But it fell flat, disappointing food that was bland and flavorless, and fresh pressed juice that had way too much pulp. If you go for anything, they have Chaga Coffee that was delicious, and a few vegan desserts that would be a nice pair.
  • Fancy’s Southern Cafe: Easily overlooked because of it’s location in a strip mall, Fancy’s is a great spot for brunch and has a very vintage, eclectic setting. Sophisticated southern is what came to mind, with a beautiful dark wood bar and unique lighting. They’re famous for their Chicken and Waffles, along with their house made doughnuts that are similar to beignets

    From the corrugated tin ceiling to the cypress wood walls, and whitewashed bricks to the impressive centerpiece—a large, rustic, wrought iron chandelier hung with jelly jar-encased lights, it’s quite the surprise from it’s unassuming strip mall location.
  • First Watch Cafe: If you’re craving avocado toast, seasonal specials, and healthy, real food choices, this cute breakfast spot is a must. Their fresh juice was great too. This is a chain, but think of it as a higher end Panera with local vibes.
Bennett's Fresh Roast - Fort Myers Florida
Bennett's Fresh Roast - Donut Shop, Fort Myers Florida
Six Local Places to Eat in Fort Myers, Florida
Green Cup Organic Cafe, downtown Fort Myers
Green Cup Organic Cafe, downtown Fort Myers
vintage desk lamp and scene
Fancy's Southern Cafe, Fort Myers
Fancy's Southern Cafe, Fort Myers

Favorite Places to Eat on Sanibel Island:

  • The Island Cow: This locally owned spot is adorned with bright colors and an airy, island feel that is really welcoming. I loved the vintage decor. We went for breakfast after trying to catch a sunrise at the beach, and really enjoyed our meal. The Shrimp Oscar Omelet was our favorite, along with the Tropical Fruit Parfait.
  • Gramma Dot’s Seaside Saloon: Tucked into the Sanibel Marina, you’ll find incredible fried oysters and be able to gaze at all the huge boats you wish you owned. Super fresh seafood, a homey feel, and beautiful seaside views. And really great key lime pie.
The Island Cow, Sanibel Island -- Where to Eat in Fort Myers, Florida
Six Local Places to Eat in Fort Myers, Florida

Top picks to Eat in Fort Myers Beach:

  • Heavenly Biscuit: This cute little cottage serves up some of the most affordable, most delicious breakfast/brunch in the area. The locals love it, and you’ll be able to see that by the bikes parked outside, and often a line out the door. The dining area is small, but has both indoor and outdoor seating, but worth arriving early. The incredible cinnamon rolls and buttermilk biscuit breakfast sandwich are a must! Important note, this is a cash only restaurant.
  • Dixie Fish Co.: This was our favorite dinner spot, right on the water in Fort Myers Beach. Built in 1937, and having gone through many-a-hurricane, the building still stands today where it not only harnesses character, but also delicious grouper (coconut crusted!) and “pink gold” shrimp, truly what Southwest Florida is known for.  The Dixie’s tin roof, wide open, windowless atmosphere is the perfect place to enjoy a sunset and dinner.

So if you find yourself in Fort Myers visiting family, spring break, or for the deep-sea fishing and famous white sand beaches, bring all your warm weather clothes, sunglasses, and a hat. The sun is quite direct for northern folk! ☺️

Also, to note, a renovation of the city’s downtown waterfront has brought in new restaurants, clubs, shops, and galleries. We didn’t have time to get to the the winter estates of Henry Ford and Thomas Edison, but it’s on our list for next time.


Pitaya Smoothie Bowl // Great Local Places to Eat in Fort Myers, Florida // Knotty Bean Coffee Bar
Dixie Fish Co, Fort Myers Beach

Did you make this?

tag @heartbeetkitchen on instagram and hashtag it #heartbeetkitchen

March 6, 2018


I look forward to your comments, reviews and questions! If you love this recipe, please rate it when you leave a comment. Star ratings help people discover my recipes. Your support means a lot; thank you for being a part of the Heartbeet Kitchen community.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. Aj

    Sad to say many of the restaurants you have mentioned are no longer open due to Ian. Unless you know something we don’t. Bennet’s is gone, island cow is partnering with another Sanibel group and they have oopened a new place. Heavenly Biscuit is now a food truck as the building is gone also. Fort myers beach is renovating and rebuilding with many old-made new places and well as new restaurants and food trucks to try out.

  2. Beth Mitchell

    Hello! Great informative blog! Can you tell me where the açaí bowl came from? We are staying in fort myers beach area this summer

    • Amanda Paa

      Unfortunately the place where I got the acai bowl closed! Uhmaze Bowls in Fort Myers is relatively new though, and their bowls are fabulous!

  3. Lisa

    Kenwood Lane Grille has been voted one of the best handmade burgers in town. It’s a fabulous hidden gem. We go every time we are in town. Def great food! Thanks

  4. Caleb

    Thank you for hosting. Have a great week.