These easy sourdough peanut butter blossoms are soft, chewy, and a little dense in the middle, with big peanut butter flavor! Instead of the usual Hershey's Kiss, each cookie gets a piece of dark chocolate pressed right into the center. Sourdough discard keeps them tender and is a great way to use up the extra starter sitting in your fridge. A must for your holiday cookie boxes and platters!
These iconic holiday cookies are pure nostalgia for me.
My mom and I made peanut butter blossoms together every year, rolling them in red and green sugar, and pressing a chocolate star (if you’re from the Midwest, you know the ones I’m talking about, straight from Menards or Fleet Farm) in the middle. So when I started baking with sourdough discard, these were high on my list, right next to my double ginger molasses sourdough cookies.
Mom’s will always be the original, but the discard keeps mine extra soft and gives them a little something extra in the flavor department. And the texture is what really gets me. You sink your teeth into the slightly firm chocolate first, then hit the dense, chewy peanut butter cookie underneath. Yum.
I started with my chewy sourdough peanut butter cookies and made a few tweaks.
If you’ve made any of my sourdough discard cookies, you know how much I love a chewy center you can sink your teeth into. For these, I added slightly more flour so the cookies have enough structure to hold up the chocolate pressed into the middle.
Then I added a little more peanut butter, too. I love drippy, natural peanut butter for toast, but it’s a no-go for these cookies. It separates, and all that oil makes the cookies greasy and crumbly. The “natural” creamy or standard creamy Jif or Skippy gives you the perfect spread and that chewy center.
I put chocolate on top that I actually want to eat.
No offense to the Hershey’s Kiss, but it’s not my favorite. So I use a piece of Dove dark chocolate instead. It’s smooth and rich, and that little bit of bitterness is just right against all the sweet, salty peanut butter. Promise, you won’t miss the kiss!
While the chocolate is still melted, I put a combination of these natural holiday sprinkles and these natural red jimmies on top. Not only do they look so festive, but they’re soft so you don’t hurt your teeth eating them!
Chewy Sourdough Peanut Butter Blossoms
These sourdough discard peanut butter blossoms are intensely chewy with the most beautiful crackled top and a piece of dark chocolate in the middle! They're perfectly salted with a hint of vanilla, and hold their shape well. The rich, dense center is everything!
Cream butter for 1 minute on medium high. Stop and scrape down sides of bowl. Then add sugars; cream for at least 2 more more minutes, until light in color and fluffy. Scrape down sides a few times during mixing, as needed.
Add peanut butter and sourdough discard, and mix on medium for about 45 seconds, until the mixture is mostly homogenous. It doesn't have to be perfect. Add egg and vanilla, and mix on low for 45 seconds to combine, scraping down sides.
In a bowl, combine flour, baking powder, baking soda, salt. Whisk to combine.
Add dry mixture in two increments to the wet ingredients, with stand mixer on speed 2, low. Turn up speed to medium for 30ish seconds to fully combine, just until no flour streaks are left. Don't overmix. Refrigerate dough for 2 hours* (up to 24 hours) to allow dough to rest and absorb liquids.
When ready to bake, preheat oven to 375 degrees F. Scoop dough into 30 to 35 gram dough balls. Place 9 dough balls on a parchment lined baking sheet with room in between.
Bake for 10 minutes, then remove pan and press dark chocolate piece into the center. Put back in the oven for 1 to 2 more minutes to slightly melt the chocolate. Remove cookies from oven and let cool on pan for 5 minutes before transfer to cooling rack. Add festive sprinkles while the chocolate is melted, before setting again.
Notes
* The dough can be made a day ahead of time and will perform beautifully for baking. The dough also freezes well. * Do NOT decrease the amount of sugar; they are not too sweet. The amount of sugar used makes them perfectly salty sweet and allows them to achieve the superbly chewy texture.*I highly recommend using an inexpensive oven thermometer when you are baking, as no oven is calibrated exactly precise, even one that is brand new. Your other likely runs hotter or cooler than it actually reads, and this can determine how much your cookies spread or do not spread and if they will look and taste like the recipe was written for. Using an oven thermometer allows you to slightly adjust the temperature to make it correct.
I look forward to your comments, reviews and questions! If you love this recipe, please rate it when you leave a comment. Star ratings help people discover my recipes. Your support means a lot; thank you for being a part of the Heartbeet Kitchen community.